It’s hard to see a world wherein this show gets interesting, based on the pilot alone. The seeds planted feel generic, and the more timely elements — like the situation at the border — not particularly well-engaged. Pilots are, by their very nature, incredibly hard to pull off well: a lot of establishing information has to be given to the audience while also introducing the plot in a way that invites continued investment. But after watching the Walker pilot, it’s hard to want to watch another episode, let alone a full season (which The CW has already ordered). The whole thing leaves one wondering: what was the reason this new version was so necessary right now?
Verdict
The CW’s Walker is a total yawn. A generic, paint-by-numbers family drama that offers some hints at the possibility for telling timely stories in the future – albeit in a Very Special Episode sort of way – the series does little to reimagine itself in a compelling way. Though the series’ star is likely the reason any of this is happening to begin with, Padalecki is unable to give us a reason to really care about this character beyond things we’ve already seen a thousand times before. If you’re going to make a show about law enforcement in 2020-21, there really needs to be a deeper investigation of — or at least an interest in — what this job really entails, not just a romanticized Hollywood version of it. Walker, at least in its pilot, engages in none of that work, leaving a lot to be desired.