Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree Garners Controversy Amidst GotY Nomination

Guides, Other

FromSoftware’s Dominance

FromSoftware is well-known for consistently delivering top-quality games in the industry. However, the nomination of Shadow of the Erdtree for Game of the Year has raised some eyebrows. Some gamers feel that it is unfair to other deserving titles that have made a mark in the industry. Twitter user @RinoTheBouncer pointed out the perceived favoritism, stating “The Game Awards appears to have bent the rules this year to include Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree in the Game of the Year category nominees, when last year, Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty was snubbed, despite being superior in every way, and transformative to the main game.”

https://x.com/RinoTheBouncer/status/1858567258445848682

While FromSoftware’s track record speaks for itself, with titles like Phantom Liberty being overlooked in the past, there are other notable games in contention this year. Games like Metaphor: ReFantazio and Black Myth: Wukong have captured audiences with their unique and innovative gameplay. Even indie titles like Balatro deserve recognition for their fresh take on gaming.

Despite FromSoftware’s reputation for creating cultural touchstones in the gaming world, some players feel that the Game Awards may be showing bias towards the studio. However, it’s important to acknowledge that many of their games have not received the top honor of Game of the Year in the past.

Lack of Fairness

Elden Ring has already secured the Game of the Year title in 2022, and the potential for Shadow of the Erdtree to win again raises concerns among gamers. While the DLC is undoubtedly a meaningful addition to the game, it is still part of the overall Elden Ring experience. Some feel that creating a separate category for game expansions and DLCs at the Game Awards could help maintain fairness and objectivity in the selection process.

FromSoftware has established itself as a powerhouse in the gaming industry, setting a high standard for quality. However, it is essential to give other developers a chance to shine and be recognized for their contributions to the gaming landscape.