As Halloween approaches, there’s nothing quite like dimming the lights and diving into some thrilling board games. If you’re eager to host a spine-tingling tabletop game night, the current Prime Day discounts are here to help, offering considerable markdowns on several top picks.
Notable titles like Mysterium, Betrayal at House on the Hill, Nemesis, and Mansions of Madness have been discounted significantly this Prime Day—making it an ideal time to snag them at a fraction of their usual prices. Whether you’re preparing for a spine-chilling evening or just want to expand your board game collection, now is the perfect opportunity. Just keep in mind that the Prime Day offers will be available only until October 8. If you’re not already a Prime member, you might want to consider Amazon’s free trial, which can unlock these deals for you.
Nemesis
Price: $159.99 $106.48 at Amazon Save $53
This title has earned significant acclaim, including a five-star rating from my friend and seasoned contributor, Ian Stokes, who regards it as his favorite horror board game. Given that its regular price hovers around $143, this discount is an excellent opportunity. If you appreciate exploration-focused games with an air of tension and mystery about trust, Nemesis is a must-have.
Buy it if:
- You enjoy cooperative games with unexpected twists
- You’re looking for a genuinely eerie experience
Don’t buy it if:
- You prefer shorter, more straightforward games
Betrayal at House on the Hill
Price: $55.99 $39.02 at Amazon Save $17
This is one of my favorite horror-themed games, which is no surprise given the enthusiastic praise in my review of the 3rd Edition. It seamlessly combines accessibility with strategic elements, effectively capturing the essence of schlocky horror films as you explore a haunted house filled with 50 unique scenarios. With its usual price rarely dropping below $45, this offers great value.
Buy it if:
- You want a game suitable for all ages this Halloween
- You enjoy a blend of strategic gameplay
Don’t buy it if:
- You seek something with deeper mechanics
Twisted Cryptids
Price: $20 $14.99 at Amazon Save $5
This recent addition to the board game scene has garnered excellent reviews for its engaging gameplay and charming theme, appealing to fans of cute horror. The tactical depth ensures that even if luck isn’t on your side, you still have a fighting chance. My colleague, Katie Wickens, has lauded it, leading it to quickly climb my personal wishlist.
Buy it if:
- You’re in the mood for a fast-paced, fun Halloween game
- You prefer whimsical over frightful
Don’t buy it if:
- You’re after a truly terrifying experience
Horrified
Price: $39.99 $27.99 at Amazon Save $12
This original title has retained its place as a classic since its release, successfully delivering Halloween thrills. You work together to defeat iconic monsters like Dracula and the Creature from the Black Lagoon—each requiring distinct strategies to conquer. The more you focus on these tactics, the more likely you are to save innocent villagers. The current price is a solid discount from its usual $40.
Buy it if:
- You thrive in team-based games
- You have a fondness for classic horror figures
Don’t buy it if:
- You want something with more intense scares
Alien: Fate of The Nostromo
Price: $34.99 $24.49 at Amazon Save $10
If you’re looking for a more accessible gaming experience, this adaptation of the original Alien film offers surprising depth while being easy to pick up. It’s perfect for those who might not have the time or the inclination for more complex games, yet it’s still packed with tension that will linger long after the game ends.
Buy it if:
- You’re new to board gaming
- You prefer simpler gameplay
Don’t buy it if:
- You desire a more layered strategic experience
Mysterium
Price: $54.99 $33.49 at Amazon Save $21
This wonderfully creepy game is ideal for teams. One player embodies a murder victim trying to provide clues to their friends about the circumstances of their demise using abstract visuals. The remaining players must piece these clues together before time runs out, creating a unique challenge for everyone. Typically priced around $43, this is a bargain at its current rate.
Buy it if:
- You love creative team games
- You’re looking for something a bit different
Don’t buy it if:
- You want a highly strategic game
Mansions of Madness
Price: $119.99 $74.49 at Amazon Save $45
If you’re a fan of Betrayal at House on the Hill and seek something with more complexity, look no further than Mansions of Madness. This game expands upon familiar horror concepts while incorporating Cthulhu mythos and features an interactive app to enhance gameplay. Regularly priced closer to $86, this sale is a considerable savings.
Buy it if:
- You’re after a more intricate horror experience
- You appreciate cosmic horror narratives
Don’t buy it if:
- You’re not fond of integrating apps into gameplay
If you’re limited to one choice, I recommend prioritizing Betrayal at House on the Hill for its accessibility and eerie atmosphere. However, if a more involved game that focuses on strategy sounds appealing, Nemesis is the way to go.