Unfrosted Review – IGN

The Biggest Joke in Unfrosted

The comedic genius behind Unfrosted is evident from the very start, as the movie humorously explores the creation of Pop-Tarts. Despite the star-studded cast including Jerry Seinfeld, Melissa McCarthy, Hugh Grant, Jim Gaffigan, and Amy Schumer, the film falls flat due to a lack of comedic timing and chemistry.

An Exaggerated Tale

Unfrosted takes a farcical approach to a corporate-approved story surrounding the rivalry between Kellogg’s and Post in the creation of toaster pastries. The whimsical world of Unfrosted is filled with absurd scenarios like mishaps at a NASA facility and a Pop-Tart engineer receiving “full cereal honors” in his burial. Despite the over-the-top nature of the film, it struggles to fully embrace its own absurdity.

A Mixed Bag of Performances

While Jerry Seinfeld juggles multiple roles in Unfrosted, the performances feel lackluster and derivative. The supporting actors, like Jim Gaffigan and Melissa McCarthy, fail to bring anything new to their characters. The film relies heavily on established personas rather than exploring new comedic territory.

Unfrosted’s Troubled Execution

Despite the talent involved in Unfrosted, the film’s disjointed nature becomes apparent as it progresses. The visual humor often falls flat, relying too heavily on funny costumes rather than genuine wit. Seinfeld’s directorial vision lacks depth, resulting in a film that fails to elevate its premise beyond surface-level comedy.

Seinfeld’s Signature Style

Despite its shortcomings, Unfrosted retains Jerry Seinfeld’s distinct comedic voice. The film delves into Seinfeld’s nostalgic musings on ’50s and ’60s pop culture, creating a personal touch amidst the mediocrity. While Unfrosted may not be a cinematic masterpiece, it does offer a glimpse into Seinfeld’s unique perspective on the world.